Working context
An audience is a group of people with different questions, not a single person with a single need. Positioning is the practice of deciding how a message or an organization should be understood by the people it addresses, and it begins with what those people already know and care about. This guide shows how to build that picture from evidence you actually hold rather than from assumption.
Bayshore Agency approaches positioning as a question of relevance and honesty. A position that cannot be explained in a sentence a reader would recognize, or that rests on claims you cannot support, tends to fall apart on contact with a real customer or colleague. The sections below follow a hypothetical community pottery studio through the process, then offer a checklist for your own work.
SECTION 01Separate what you know from what you assume
Start by sorting statements about your audience into three piles: things you have observed, things you have been told and things you believe. Imagine a hypothetical pottery studio that says its audience is creative people who want to relax. Observed facts might be that most booking questions arrive by email on weekday evenings and ask about beginner sessions. Reported facts might include a handful of comments about parking. The belief about relaxation is an interpretation that may or may not hold. Label each statement, note its source and date, and decide which beliefs deserve a quick test before they shape any message. This keeps a planning document from hardening assumptions into facts.
SECTION 02Write a positioning statement a reader would recognize
A usable positioning statement names who the message is for, what need or situation it addresses and why the approach is relevant, in language the audience would use themselves. For the pottery studio, a draft might read: for adults who have never thrown clay, a small-group introduction that explains each step before the wheel starts. Read it aloud and ask whether a newcomer would recognize themselves in it. Remove superlatives such as best or leading unless you can show the evidence. Then check consistency: the website, the booking email and the sign on the door should all support the same position. Contradictions between them tell readers more than any slogan.
SECTION 03Test relevance with small, respectful checks
You do not need a large study to learn whether a message lands. Ask three or four existing contacts, with their consent, to describe in their own words what they believe the offer is for. Compare their phrasing with yours. Look at the questions that arrive after a message goes out; repeated questions about the same detail suggest the original was unclear. Where audiences differ, such as first-time visitors and returning members, consider whether one position can serve both or whether the message needs two entry points. Keep notes of what you changed and why, so that the next revision starts from reasoning rather than memory. Small samples show direction, not proof.
Checks to carry into the decision
- List what you have observed about your audience separately from what you assume or have been told.
- Describe one typical reader's situation in two sentences, without naming a real person.
- Draft a positioning statement and read it aloud to someone outside your team.
- Remove any claim of being best, first or leading that you cannot support with evidence.
- Check that your website, emails and printed material describe the same position.
- Ask a few existing contacts, with consent, what they think the offer is for.
How to get the most from it
Begin with audience and positioning to decide who a message is for, use planning and channel choices to pick a format, and finish with measurement and learning to review what happened. Each guide follows a small hypothetical example, such as a pottery studio or a garden club, that you can adapt to your own situation.
Common questions
Questions readers ask
What is the difference between positioning and a slogan?
Positioning is the underlying decision about who a message serves and why it is relevant. A slogan is one possible way of expressing it. You can have a clear position with no slogan at all, but a slogan with no position behind it tends to sound pleasant and say nothing. Settle the decision first, then see whether a short phrase helps.
How many audience groups should one plan cover?
Only as many as you can describe from evidence and serve with distinct messages. Two or three groups with real differences, such as new inquirers and returning customers, usually give more useful direction than a long list of personas. If you cannot say how a message would change for a group, that group may not need its own section yet.
Can I use a competitor's wording to learn about positioning?
You can read it to understand how others frame similar needs, but copying the wording invites confusion and may make claims you cannot support. Use it as a contrast: what do they emphasize, what do they leave out, and which questions from your own audience go unanswered? Those gaps often show where your explanation can be more useful.
Bringing it together
Positioning is not a one-off exercise. Audiences change, and a statement that was accurate last year may need a small correction after you listen to what people ask. Keep the evidence file, the draft statement and your revision notes together, and revisit them when something meaningful shifts. If you want outside help, seek a qualified professional and bring those notes with you.
These guides are general education about marketing and communications, not a strategy for any particular organization, so confirm legal, regulatory and budget questions with qualified advisers.
